# Category Archives: Open discussion

## The Polynomial Hirsch Conjecture: Discussion Thread

This post is devoted to the polymath-proposal about the polynomial Hirsch conjecture. My intention is to start here a discussion thread on the problem and related problems. (Perhaps identifying further interesting related problems and research directions.) Earlier posts are: The polynomial Hirsch … Continue reading

Posted in Convex polytopes, Open discussion, Open problems | Tagged , | 115 Comments

## The Polynomial Hirsch Conjecture – How to Improve the Upper Bounds.

I can see three main avenues toward making progress on the Polynomial Hirsch conjecture. One direction is trying to improve the upper bounds, for example,  by looking at the current proof and trying to see if it is wasteful and if so where … Continue reading

Posted in Convex polytopes, Open discussion, Open problems | Tagged , | 14 Comments

## The Polynomial Hirsch Conjecture, a Proposal for Polymath3 (Cont.)

The Abstract Polynomial Hirsch Conjecture A convex polytope is the convex hull of a finite set of points in a real vector space. A polytope can be described as the intersection of a finite number of closed halfspaces. Polytopes have … Continue reading

Posted in Convex polytopes, Open discussion, Open problems | | 5 Comments

## The Polynomial Hirsch Conjecture: A proposal for Polymath3

This post is continued here.  Eddie Kim and Francisco Santos have just uploaded a survey article on the Hirsch Conjecture. The Hirsch conjecture: The graph of a d-polytope with n vertices  facets has diameter at most n-d. We devoted several … Continue reading

## An Open Discussion and Polls: Around Roth’s Theorem

Suppose that  is a subset of of maximum cardinality not containing an arithmetic progression of length 3. Let . How does behave? We do not really know. Will it help talking about it? Can we somehow look beyond the horizon and try to guess what … Continue reading

Posted in Combinatorics, Open discussion, Open problems | | 27 Comments

## Is Mathematics a Science?

Many people do not regard mathematics as a science since it does not directly probe our physical reality; some mathematicians even like to think about mathematics as being closer to art, music or literature. But is there really a big … Continue reading

Posted in Open discussion, Philosophy, What is Mathematics | | 7 Comments