Ordinary computers can beat Google’s quantum computer after all

Science magazine has an article written by Adrian Cho Ordinary computers can beat Google’s quantum computer after all. It is about the remarkable progress in classical simulations of sampling task like those sampling tasks that led to the 2019 Google’s announcement of “quantum supremacy”. I reported about the breakthrough paper of Feng Pan and Pan Zhang in this post and there are updates in the post itself and the comment section about a variety of related works by several groups of researchers.

The very short summary is that by now classical algorithms are ten orders of magnitude faster than those used in the Google paper and hence the speed-up is ten orders of magnitude lower than Google’s fantastic claims. (The Google paper claims that their ultimate task that required 300 seconds for the quantum computer will require 10,000 years on a powerful supercomputers. with the new algorithms the task can be done in a matter of seconds.)

Also regarding the Google supremacy paper, my paper with Yosi Rinott and Tomer Shoham,  Statistical Aspects of the Quantum Supremacy Demonstration, just appeared in “Statistical Science”. (Click on the link for the journal version.) The Google 2019 paper and, more generally, NISQ experiments raise various interesting statistical issues. (In addition, it is important to double check various statistical claims of the paper.) One of our findings is that there is a large gap between the empirical distribution and the Google noise model. I hope to devote some future post to our paper and to some further research we were doing.

The leaking of the Google paper in September 23, 2019 led to huge media and academic attention and many very enthusiastic reactions.  I also wrote here on the blog a few critical posts about the Google claims.

Here is a figure with the price of bitcoin around the time of the Google quantum supremacy (unintended) announcement.

bc666

This entry was posted in Quantum, Updates and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Ordinary computers can beat Google’s quantum computer after all

  1. - says:

    Could the google quantum supremacy announcement have something to do with manipulating the Bitcoin price?

  2. Thanks for saving me the time to understand a paper that may not have the desired payoff.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s